religiousdiscussion | Unsorted

Telegram-канал religiousdiscussion - Religious Discussion

213

Discuss and evaluate various aspects of religion and religious beliefs so that we may further our understanding. 1. Stay on topic 2. Be respectful; no trolls/fascists 3. No spam 4. No NSFW 5. Be open minded 6. English only @ReligiousDiscussionChannel

Subscribe to a channel

Religious Discussion

Yes thats the difference between perfect God and human beings. God’s prediction is equal to future. And human predictions are possibilities

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

Absolute free will = you could genuinely do otherwise in the exact same conditions.
Non-absolute (compatibilist) free will = you act according to your own desires and reasons, even if the outcome is already known.
Knowing ≠ forcing. A weather forecast can predict rain without causing it but perfect foreknowledge means only one future is possible. So your choice can be free in motive, but not “open” in outcome.

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

Thats what im saying humans aren’t but they are 60-70% correctly estimate the future ? Like a civil engineer to his construction and a meteorologist to weather. This is sign of perfection to know future 100% and God supposed to be perfect. And knowledge doesn’t mean that you’ve forced someone to do a particular thing.

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

Humans aren't 100% omniscient, God is. Free will is subjective to God's omniscience. If God knows what you'll do at a point in time, you can't do something else which will go against his omniscience. Free will isn't absolute.

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

And having knowledge is not forcing someone

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

There are 4 hierarchy of life styles:
1) Life of pleasure: which is soley based on instincts of the stomach and the private parts, and cheap dopamine.
2) Life of Achievements: a work-centric existence that breeds professional success but often leads to severe imbalance and the neglect of spiritual or social needs.
3) A step above would be "the good life" characterized by healthy equilibrium (sports, social life, personal happiness), yet remains fundamentally self-centered.
4) Meaningful life: where an individual maintains balance but also dedicates themselves to a purpose greater than their own ego—such as faith, service to Muslims, or spreading knowledge—transforming them into a servant of a noble, lasting cause.

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

Everything is by the will of Allah

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

I don't think what we would call Divine Intervention is what's happening from God's perspective. There are parts of Creätion which are wholly divinely existent, like the stars or the laws of physics and there are parts we get to assume a measure of coäuthorship, our own free will and creätivity. The fraction of that measure is known only to God, but I don't believe it's zero. "Frozen" implies Time. The Time of Creätion and the Time of Heaven need not be on the same lines.

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

I mean does God have any reaction to this block of frozen Cosmos, let's say?

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

Although we don't know what time actually is and if it is real or an illusion
We only experience time as a linear universal flow

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

are the works of the crow predetermined or not? he also has a small brain... but we know what he will do and why. this is predetermined. maybe the details are also predetermined. because every act leads to the next

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

by the readiness to be changed and to learn what are life priorities, only god can help with this. man cant change his own intention by himself.

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

Neuroscience shows that up to 95% of our decisions may be made by the unconscious mind before we're even aware of them.

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

Yes, God hardened his heart
Yunus 88
And Moses said, “Our Lord, indeed You have given Pharaoh and his establishment splendor and wealth in the worldly life, our Lord, that they may lead [men] astray from Your way. Our Lord, obliterate their wealth and harden their hearts so that they will not believe until they see the painful punishment.”
89
[Allah] said, “Your supplication has been answered.” So remain on a right course and follow not the way of those who do not know.”

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

No, it's okay! Nothing to apologize for.

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

Choosing something that's predestined isn't free will

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

“If God knows what you'll do at a point in time, you can't do something else”

Whatever you’ll do God knows it. Like you got ABCDEFGH options, you’ll choose which God already knows by use of your free will

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

What is the difference between absolute and non absolute free will ?

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

For ex. A car engineer knows timeline of the car and what problems can occur in the car by the time. A human can have knowledge of car’s future by estimation then why not God.

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

If god doesn’t have knowledge of future he isn’t God

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

Free will and Omniscient God can't coexist.

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

Those different accounts are modern reconstructions that attempts to reconcile the story with current moral discomfort. They're not from the primary texts that are widely accepted and are the most authoritative sources in Islam.

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

if he experiences it all at once

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

Do you believe God has actions that have order? Or is he like a frozen block that doesn't have actions? Does he interfere with time all at once?

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

It reminds me of Pennywise
An unknown, extra dimensional entity for whom the past, present and future are one and the same

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

any act man does comes from the desire to comfort himself or reach a better state or situation. this is automatic and predetermined. like when one gets cold, he seeks warmth, like a beast with a brain

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

They are pre-determined. But you can change them if you change the intention

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

for their pride and corruption, Moses prayed that they would miss the guidance of god . and god responded

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

I am not. I believe my choices are not predetermined.

Читать полностью…

Religious Discussion

No offense taken, but one of the chat rules is that everything must be Safe For Work. The topic of eroticism is allowed, but erotic imagery is not allowed.

Читать полностью…
Subscribe to a channel