213
Discuss and evaluate various aspects of religion and religious beliefs so that we may further our understanding. 1. Stay on topic 2. Be respectful; no trolls/fascists 3. No spam 4. No NSFW 5. Be open minded 6. English only @ReligiousDiscussionChannel
I agree only on the point that some muslims try to make false modern cosmological explanations, and take it as 100% facts, I don't think that's correct.
Читать полностью…
I didn't intend that the explanation of the falling of the sky is the real explaination, I can't confirm this is 100% the real explaination/essence, because this is among (the unseen, elm el ghayb), but I am demonstrating how you cherry picked the flat earth model and then applied the quran on it to critize the Quran, I am showing that various explanations are possible.
Ibn Abbas himself considered the structure of the sama is among the unseen (Elm el ghayb) that no one knows its structural essence except Allah, ibn abbas tafsir was simply confirming the Quranic facts that the sky has doors and a ceiling, and a building. It's not nessary that this "building" is something we can measure or see, as Allah said the sky is held by pillars, but we can't measure it or see it by our limited knowledge. There is no embarrassment, I admit the sky is something that is built and strictured and also held, but I don't believe that it is nessary that we can measure it by scientific materalism, your saying science shows that mostly space is vacuum while the quran says sky is ceiling, I will say again and again that the sky is all that is above us, a vast expense of space, galaxies, planets, stars, and galaxies, all of this exists within the bounds of the lowest hevean, they are all contents inside it (the Sama' al-Dunya).
Allah says: "And We have certainly beautified the nearest heaven with stars..." (Qur'an 67:5). So the actual "ceiling" is a boundary in which human telescopes would probably never reach, because it's a boundary of all that. Science observes the vacuum beneath the ceiling; it has not reached the ceiling itself. There is absolutely no contradiction in acknowledging that the space between us and the physical boundary of the lowest heaven is predominantly a vacuum.
Your saying ((You can't have pieces of a vacuum falling on your head, and you can't have pillars holding up empty space)) This is confusing vacuum with the structure itself, Because we affirm that the heaven is a physical structure enclosing this universe [It's not nessary that we can observe or measure it], then naturally, if Allah commands it to break apart (such as on the Day of Judgment), literal pieces of that massive structure can fall. It is not the "vacuum" that falls; it is the physical heaven itself. The Qur'an states Allah raised the heavens "without pillars that you can see" (Qur'an 13:2). Ibn Abbas himself stated this means there are pillars, but they are unseen to us, or it means there are no pillars at all, but rather the immense structure is held up purely by the power of Allah. Either way, it describes a magnificent physical creation, not empty space.
You can even research yourself that many muslims used to see heaven as physical
And today it's a mix of physical (from Qur'an interpretation) and metaphysical (from people's perspective)
this is what will always come about from vague or interpretive text that claims to be the absolute truth
its interpretation will always be adapted either to facilitate power or to modernize it to the culture it serves
The verse says he holds the sky from falling except by his authority. If we see it from a scientific perspective, what holds the universe? physical laws, so as long as allah make these physical laws preserve the universe as it is then the earth will remain peaceful
Читать полностью…
we do know what falling is
or we can model what it means to be gravitationally attracted to something
and physical laws aren’t disturbed
i’m not sure what you mean by that
a lot of astronomy’s been finding out earth’s place in the universe is not unique
does allah also hold the sky above venus and mars?
what’s the point of even making that distinction if the earth isn’t at the center of it all? it’s clear in the context of the verses provided that the writer believes his place to be central in the universe when we now know it isn’t
So the divine defines the reality of Allah, what he is.
Brahman also represents the reality of Brhaman (that includes us too). Then maybe that's divinity: our true form. But on the surface the projection isn't divine itself because we are not free from ego and sufferings. Well it depends on how we use the term divine. Even without using this term, religion makes sense.(Because I can still explain manifestation, brahman and us) So I don’t need to forcefully impose this term on my religion just because others do.
My battery is dead, goodnight
isra'
85. And they ask you, [O Muhammad], about the soul. Say, "The soul is of the affair [i.e., concern] of my Lord. And you [i.e., mankind] have not been given of knowledge except a little."
the sincerity
1. Say, "He is Allah, [who is] One,
2. Allah, the Eternal Refuge.
3. He neither begets nor is born,
4. Nor is there to Him any equivalent."
i have some answer. but i cant use my own words. may make a mistake
Читать полностью…
What actually divine means? What actually pure means?
Читать полностью…
and you are under danger of misinterpretations and philosophy if you dont have a book that clears all your contradictions. there is only one book that does that. it is the quran
Читать полностью…
which cosmological explanations do you think are false?
Читать полностью…
This already assumes a being that influences the physical world which needs proving.
Читать полностью…
Earlier scholars had different views
Ibn Abbas Muhammad’s own cousin
and the Prophet literally prayed for him to have the best understanding of the Quran’s secrets. If anyone knew what "Seven Heavens" meant, it was him. But when you look at him and his students actual explanations, he doesn't talk about a vacuum, an observable universe or symbolic metaphors. They describe a very physical, stacked building with gates, guards and stars that function as literal lamps and missiles. He and his students took every word literally because they believed the Quran was a clear map of the world, not a collection of riddles waiting for 21st-century science to solve (even today science didn't find it similar)
Today’s modern scholars are essentially "translating for God" to avoid embarrassment. They find themselves in a trap: if they admit the sky is a "solid roof" (as the Arabic word Saqf and early scholars like Ibn Abbas insisted), then the Quran is scientifically wrong. So they start twisting the definitions. They’ll call expansion word miracle and conveniently skip or "re-interpret" the verse right next to it that says a "piece" of the sky can fall on your head. You cant have a piece of a vacuum and you can't have pillars (even invisible ones) holding up empty space.
In the end, they have only two choices. Either change the meaning of the words or reject modern discoveries or call it fake (what they did initially)
You are saying that many scholars today would not agree. The reason seems to be that they feel they have no other option but to connect the Qur'an with modern discoveries. However the Qur'an never clearly mentions the modern concept of the universe which is mostly vacuum
Instead it uses the word ceiling to describe the sky. If the meaning of the ceiling is changed just to fit modern science even though no alternative meaning is given in the Qur'an then another problem appears. The text also talks about people sinking into the earth or the sky falling in pieces. In a vacuum there is nothing to sink into which makes such descriptions difficult to interpret literally
Even if you say maybe the first heaven is observable and the rest isnt then its not what you picked from the Qur'an. The Qur'an calls it as a ceiling and if you change the meaning of ceiling to universe even if there's no different meaning available in Qur'an then still you will ignore sinking into (since there's vacuum in space you can't sink)
I had written more points earlier and saved them in my clipboard. Unfortunately many of them were replaced so I will have to rewrite them again later. Right now I have to leave for my workout
idk if we can consider the earth to be peaceful
if we look at its history we see natural laws destroying life on earth catastrophically through meteors or geological events
The verse says falling on earth, it talks about the human perspective.
Читать полностью…
big boy einstein formalized it in general relativity
Читать полностью…
"held" here can be explained as holding the universe from collapsing or destroyed, the celestial bodies in it or the cosmic smoke. We don't know what's the "how" of falling here.
Читать полностью…
ya seen 77-83
77. Does man not consider that We created him from a [mere] sperm-drop – then at once he is a clear adversary?
78. And he presents for Us an example and forgets his [own] creation. He says, "Who will give life to bones while they are disintegrated?"
79. Say, "He will give them life who produced them the first time; and He is, of all creation, Knowing."
80. [It is] He who made for you from the green tree, fire, and then from it you ignite.
81. Is not He who created the heavens and the earth Able to create the likes of them? Yes, [it is so]; and He is the Knowing Creator.
82. His command is only when He intends a thing that He says to it, "Be," and it is.
83. So exalted is He in whose hand is the realm of all things, and to Him you will be returned.
soul is spirit in the last verse. same word in arabic roah
Читать полностью…
naba2
38. The Day that the Spirit and the angels will stand in rows, they will not speak except for one whom the Most Merciful permits, and he will say what is correct.
39. That is the True [i.e., certain] Day; so he who wills may take to his Lord a [way of] return.
but i can show you verses that you can read. if you want
Читать полностью…
This is different from looking 'divine' into someone.
When you say Aham Brahamasmi (I'm Brahman). You're not looking for something divine, you're looking into the reality (what actually exists).