213
Discuss and evaluate various aspects of religion and religious beliefs so that we may further our understanding. 1. Stay on topic 2. Be respectful; no trolls/fascists 3. No spam 4. No NSFW 5. Be open minded 6. English only @ReligiousDiscussionChannel
al ahzab
35. Indeed, the Muslim men and Muslim women, the believing men and believing women, the obedient men and obedient women, the truthful men and truthful women, the patient men and patient women, the humble men and humble women, the charitable men and charitable women, the fasting men and fasting women, the men who guard their private parts and the women who do so, and the men who remember Allah often and the women who do so – for them Allah has prepared forgiveness and a great reward.
Surah Nuh (71:15-16):
"Do you not see how Allah has created the seven heavens in layers? And made the moon 'therein' (fīhinna) a light and made the sun a lamp?"
Problem,: The Arabic word fīhinna is plural (referring to all seven heavens). If the Sun and Moon are placed within the seven heavens as a system, it mirrors the exact layered logic of the Babylonians.
It's easy to think that stars are like wallpapers and beyond there there are moon and sun somewhere.
And if stars are shot as missiles then it means they are being hit inside the Earth's atmosphere
It means stars come first
Also shooting stars are meteoroids not stars
Babylonians had the same model but with different beliefs, they believed in multiple powerful gods
Where Islam believed in One god and jinn
Variations happen with cultural beliefs and needs
So you can't even see all of these stars/adornments.
Читать полностью…
an'am
(29) And they say, "There is not but our worldly life; we die and live, and nothing destroys us except time."
(30) And if you could see when they are made to stand before their Lord. He will say, "Is this not the truth?" They will say, "Yes, by our Lord." He will [then] say, "So taste the tornment for what you used to deny."
(31) Indeed, those who denied the meeting with Allah had lost, until when the Hour [of resurrection] came upon them suddenly, they said, "Oh, [how great is] our regret over what we neglected concerning it," while they bear their own burdens on their backs. Unquestionably, evil is that which they bear.
Thanks for coming back to eyesight vision
This is your assumption
And my assumption is that the Qur'an tried to adopt Babylonian's belief on sun, moon and other 5 planets as part of different heaven realms
I will reply to other points later, I gotta go
Читать полностью…
the verse doesnt have 'return your vision to the sky'...this is translation. the return of vision is not together with the sky. just to make you avoid taking your own interpretation for truth.
Читать полностью…
You see these different translations? The literal one is the above, it uses the word (see) but the verse means (didn't you know).
Читать полностью…
5) when you say the Sun is a star even if the Quran doesn't say it
Youu cant simply make that conclusion yourself.
Even if modern science says the Sun and stars are the same type of object, that doesn't mean the Qur'an uses those words as synonyms.
The Qur'an clearly treats them differently.
For example:
Qur'an 37:6 says stars decorate the lowest heaven.
Qur'an 67:5 says stars are used as missiles against devils.
The Sun is never described this way.
Quran 25:61 mentions the sun, moon and stars separately.
So if someone claims sun = star, that is their own interpretation.
By the same logic, someone could also claim moon is a star because the Quran never explicitly says otherwise.
But clearly the text treats them as different celestial objects
6) The verse says we cant pass the regions of the Heavens and...'the Earth' without authority.
If authority is required to leave the regions of the Earth, how did humans go to the Moon? We have clearly passed the "region of Earth"
If the missiles against Jinn are stars, ok leave this error and let's say missiles on jinn are meteor then the first heaven is physically located right above our heads in the atmosphere because this is where meteoroids turn into shooting stars because of earth environment
Concealing the Quranic messages and being shy from it is one of the biggest sins:
2:159 (Indeed, those who conceal what We sent down of clear proofs and guidance after We made it clear for the people in the Scripture - those are cursed by Allāh and cursed by those who curse) And it's obligatory on scholars to tell the real meanings of the quran:
3:187 (˹Remember, O Prophet,˺ when Allah took the covenant of those who were given the Scripture to make it known to people and not hide it, yet they cast it behind their backs and traded it for a fleeting gain. What a miserable profit!)
But when we talk about signs that are (unspecific) like allah said in 3:7 like the 7 heveans, we don't know for sure what it's actually is, you can't say to me (Muslims are hiding and manipulating verses to fit science).
Also I forgot to mention that (sama) does indeed have different meanings in the Quran depending on the context, sometimes it could mean the clouds like in : 23:18 (We send down rain from the sky in perfect measure, causing it to soak into the earth. And We are surely able to take it away.) , and sometimes (sama) means the structure that Allah build in 2 days, 41:12 (So He formed the heaven into seven heavens in two Days, assigning to each its mandate. And We adorned the lowest heaven with ˹stars like˺ lamps ˹for beauty˺ and for protection. That is the design of the Almighty, All-Knowing.”) , and for the most times it means what is above the earth containing sun and moon and stars etc...
Читать полностью…
It is the religion of mongols and turks before islam
Читать полностью…
It wasn’t a terrible incident but it was quite the surprise for the man who now has a football ⚽️ sized hole in his roof
Читать полностью…
But this bablyonian belief literally contradicts the Qur'an directly.
The Babylonian belief says that each hevean is associated with a celestial body, each level corresponded a plant.
While the Qur'an says, that el sama el dunyah , which is the first level, (and the nearest to us) contains the adornments, it didn't say that every planet has a hevean.
It can mean that we can look at all of the heavens if they're following Babylonian's belief which explains why these bodies (Moon, Mercury, Venus, Sun, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn) exist
All these bodies exist in seven heavens Or
In each heaven there are different gods (these celestial bodies)
At that time people could observe only these bodies
So in this verse, it gives the fact, saying " didn't you know", and then tells you to look.
It's too different things, and looking doesn't imply that all these heveans are inside the universe or that's in your scope
I am not saying the sky are the physical laws, I am saying it is held by physical laws, such that Allah can make the universe collapse on itself if these laws were altered, by his own will.
Читать полностью…
Well I did have to write to much because (returning the vision here) doesn't refer to the creation of the "heveans", it refers to elrahman creation generally, the verse is composed of 3 different statements:
firstly the verse: Gives the fact that Allah created the 7 heveans as layers.
(˹He is the One˺ Who created seven heavens, one above the other.)
Then gives that fact that You will never see any imperfection in the creation of the Most Compassionate.
then orders you to look. But (looking here) only refers to what's available to your eyes capacity, even if we assume that all of the seven heveans are inside the universe, then still no human being would be able to see all of the universe from earth normally.
So the (looking here) refers to ( anything that the most compassionate created in the scope of your eyes). Even if you see the classical tafsirs, you will see that they say on the looking part ( seeing 1 hevean) or ( sama), not (seeing th samawat) by plural.
As if I was saying ( Uzo, Allah created the heveans and the earth, so look at Allah's creation) Does the looking here imply that you can see all of the heveans and the earth and that all of them is available in your scope and inside the universe? No.
The seven heavens are presented as a sign
A sign is something meant to be witnessed to prove a point
The object being discussed is physically present in front of the observer
Taking vision into the past makes no sense
And calling it 'considering' also doesn't make sense because those observers can't study sky or heaven
You wouldn't have to write so much if you had read the next verse as well
The Verse: Surah Al-Mulk (67:3-4) says: "...so return your vision (al-basar). Do you see any breaks? Then return your vision twice again. Your vision will return to you weary and defeated..."
You can interpret "Do you not see" as "Do you not know"
But you cant interpret "return your physical eyesight" as "return your knowledge"
1) (Do you not see) in the Qur'an comes in the meaning of (didn't you know?/did you not consider) and this is the linguistic style of the Quran and this is well known, and there are evidences:
2:258 (Did you not consider the one who argued about Abraham about his lord because allah granted him leadership?)
@Guy_dom You told me that you like to see the arabic verb yourself in the verse, if you like that, you will see that is says ( Did you see?) (Alam tarah) That's why you will find different translations of it. Similarly in other surahs in the quran, like : (Did you not see what your lord did with the people of the elephant?) And certainly the prophet didn't saw this.
The reason the Qur'an uses the verb (see) instead of (know) because it considers that it's words is soo truthfull that it's as if is as you saw the story by your own eyes, it's a linguistic style.
How would the Allah logically ask the prophet to see something in the past where he wasn't born? He wouldn't, that's not the meaning of the verse.
A meteor struck a house near me yesterday
Читать полностью…
1) You are saying that the first heaven is observable and the other six are unseen?
But this is not what the Qur'an says
Qur'an 71:15 asks:
"Do you not see how Allah created the seven heavens in layers?"
The Qur'an literally tells people to see them
This belief is constructed later to answer a question because once science didn't find six more heavens, the explanation suddenly became "they are unseen"
That explanation clearly came out of nowhere
"Maybe the first heaven is observable but the rest are not" these are their words, not the Qur'an's words
What the Qur'an doesn't say cant simply be claimed
2) Another claim you make is that the sky refers to physical laws like gravity or cosmic order
But the Qur'an 22:65 says:
"God holds the sky from falling upon the earth except by His permission."
Physical laws do not fall
Gravity cant suddenly drop on Earth
So when the verse describes something being held from falling, the most natural reading is that it is describing something physical above the earth not abstract physics
3) no it can't be mean other celestial bodies. Quran has to mention that specific object (body) which will crash to the earth but instead it says fall of whole vast sky or heaven which is also described as ceiling
Then its not point to point collision but surface to surface collapse
4)"You can't measure the sky like a wall"
Exactly and this is a modern answer, not a Qur'anic one.
Even if modern science says the sky isnt a physical ceiling, repeating modern explanations doesn't mean the Qur'an says the same thing.
The Qur'an itself tells people to look at the sky.
For example:
Qur'an 67:3–4 tells people to look again and again and try to find flaws
And the original meaning of the word includes crack or break.
So the verse literally challenges people to look at the sky and find a crack
This only makes sense if the audience thinks the sky is something structural above them.
Because if it were talking about physical laws, then looking upward with your eyes to find a flaw makes no sense
People at that time didn't even know about cosmic laws or physics
So the praise would only work if people thought:
"Look how huge this sky is, yet it isn't falling on us"
7:57 (He is the One Who sends the winds ushering in His mercy. When they bear heavy clouds, We drive them to a lifeless land and then cause rain to fall, producing every type of fruit. Similarly, We will bring the dead to life, so perhaps you will be mindful.)
Читать полностью…
The claims of scientific miracles from the cosmological verses, and considering it as a fact and a thing to convince people to enter the Islam because of it.
Читать полностью…