213
Discuss and evaluate various aspects of religion and religious beliefs so that we may further our understanding. 1. Stay on topic 2. Be respectful; no trolls/fascists 3. No spam 4. No NSFW 5. Be open minded 6. English only @ReligiousDiscussionChannel
the story of the people of the sabbath has a wisdom to it. they were asked to not work on saturdays, and god made the fish come to the shore on saturdays. and no fish on other days. they used their intelligence to break the law without breaking it. that is still wrong.
Читать полностью…
Of course safeguards can be manipulated everything humans create can be. The point isn’t to make an absolute perfect system, it’s to reduce harm and make abuse harder, not easier. Clear rules, evidence-based standards, and accountability don’t eliminate wrongdoing, but they consistently protect more people than vague principles that rely only on someone’s judgment.
Читать полностью…
any safegaurd or law can be manipulated
Читать полностью…
Exactly and if humans are '‘unjust and ignorant’' and often get these judgments wrong and "mess up", that’s precisely why we need clear, protective rules based on evidence and harm prevention, not vague standards that can be abused. Leaving something this serious to case-by-case judgment is risky when history shows people rationalize injustice all the time. If fairness is the goal, stronger safeguards not looser ones make more sense.
Читать полностью…
yes. it is left for us to judge. and we are asked to be fair, but we always mess up
Читать полностью…
I’m not denying what the verse says I’m pointing out that it uses criteria, not a measurable rule. ‘Marriageable age’ and ‘sound judgment’ still require humans to decide what counts, and history shows those decisions change with knowledge about harm, development, and consent. That isn’t ‘disliking’ the text it’s acknowledging that applying it to real people always involves human judgment
Читать полностью…
if there is no marriagable age, why would the quran mention it?
Читать полностью…
what you say is what you say. and the verse says what it says. do not interpret it according to your desire.
Читать полностью…
nisa' 6
6. And test the orphans [in their abilities] until they reach marriageable age. Then if you perceive in them sound judgement, release their property to them. And do not consume it excessively and quickly, [anticipating] that they will grow up. And whoever, [when acting as guardian], is self-sufficient should refrain [from taking a fee]; and whoever is poor – let him take according to what is acceptable. Then when you release their property to them, bring witnesses upon them. And sufficient is Allah as Accountant.
I mean, posting a Whatever gif to an admin is sorta asking for it.
Читать полностью…
I just don't get why some people choose to behave this way
Читать полностью…
I think those who spam gifs don't take the conversation seriously, just trying to mock.
Читать полностью…
Those who are genuinely bad turn into good people because of fear of eternal punishment and those who are genuinely good they stay in the religion “the desire of pleasing God” make them do more good deeds than they would’ve done if they didn’t have any religion
Читать полностью…
so you need safeguards? and you think these safeguards wont be manipulated?
Читать полностью…
ahzab
72. Indeed, We offered the Trust to the heavens and the earth and the mountains, and they declined to bear it and feared it; but man [undertook to] bear it. Indeed, he was unjust and ignorant.
I agree that maturity isn’t just a number mental and emotional capacity matter. But because adults can easily misjudge or abuse that flexibility, societies set minimum ages as a safeguard against harm and coercion. So it’s not that age is the whole story it’s that clear age limits exist to protect people when ‘judgment’ and ‘reason’ can be biased or exploited.
Читать полностью…
in reality, there is no single biological age for marriage, i think. it is also related to reason. so it is biological and mental
Читать полностью…
so it is an age to the body and to the logic
Читать полностью…
it didnt mention a specific number, but related it to sound judgement
Читать полностью…
we see the verse mentioning ''marriagable age and having a sound judgement''. but you do not like to see the quran cutting through the falsehood.
Читать полностью…
That verse talks about testing judgment before handing over property, not setting a clear, protective minimum age for marriage. In practice, it leaves ‘marriageable age’ vague and dependent on interpretation, which is exactly why different societies and even Islamic scholars have disagreed and changed standards over time.
Читать полностью…
Christians who accept the apostolic tradition are catholics, orthodox and "high" protestant churches(to some extent).
Many of those christians don't see church fathers as infallible, which is why the fundamental teachings(doctrines)are reported in ecumenical councils or are those on which the fathers were unanimously agreed (this is a debated point).
It should also be added that the catholic church and some high protestant churches, in particular, integrate a historical-critical approach into their exegesis, in order to have a more complete vision of the texts.
I think someone becomes eligible for marriage when they are a legal adult, can give informed and voluntary consent, and have the mental and emotional maturity to understand the responsibilities involved. Age laws exist to protect people from coercion and harm, but maturity and consent matter just as much as the number. In short, marriage should require adulthood, real consent, and the capacity to make that choice freely not pressure, tradition, or authority.
Читать полностью…
I chalk it up to being abusive. They want to see how much they can get away with.
Читать полностью…
He's probably all "yeah, well, I didn't want to be a part of your stupid chat anyway."
Читать полностью…
He was just being abusive and thinks he's smart because he figured out a way to disrespect people for saying (1) something he didn't understand and (2) something he did understand. That they were literally the same thing just made it obvious.
Читать полностью…