213
Discuss and evaluate various aspects of religion and religious beliefs so that we may further our understanding. 1. Stay on topic 2. Be respectful; no trolls/fascists 3. No spam 4. No NSFW 5. Be open minded 6. English only @ReligiousDiscussionChannel
but even god’s gotta follow the logic of his own world
Читать полностью…
There was no fixed marriage age in early Islam. The Qur’an set conditions, not numbers: bulugh + rushd (maturity and sound judgment) Qur’an 4:6. Classical tafsīr (Ibn Kathīr, Qurtubī) confirms this is physical and mental readiness, not puberty alone.
Biological numbers like breastfeeding (2:233, 46:15) are descriptive, not permissions for harm. The binding rule remains no harm (Hadith Ibn Majah)
So harm from early marriage reflects human practice, not Qur’anic command.
You’re right that pelvic and cervical maturity don’t change by climate and that actually strengthens the Islamic position, not weakens it because if medical harm is real and universal then forcing marriage or pregnancy before bodily completion violates the Qur’anic principle of no harm and the command to ensure rushd The Prophet ﷺ said
There should be neither harm nor reciprocating harm (Ibn Majah)
As for pigs, alcohol, and gamblingthose were explicitly named because their harm was moral, social, and spiritual not dependent on scientific discovery physical harm on the other hand is assessed through knowledge which Islam repeatedly tells humans to seek accountability increases with knowledge.
When it comes to marriage, the Qur’an actually does give a biological and moral condition, just not a numeral. In Surah An Nisa 4:6, Allah says to test orphans until they reach marriageable age, and only then, if you find sound judgment (rushd), hand over responsibility. Classical tafsir (Ibn Kathir, Qurtubi) is clear that rushd includes physical and mental maturity not just puberty.
So Islam never said puberty readiness for marriage or pregnancy That’s an assumption made by societies not a Qur’anic command
I've already mentioned that if the no harm principle were enough, God wouldn't have needed to mention pigs, alcohol or gambling
Because in the 7th century people also didn't know that female child died because of intimacy before completion of body
I will ask you a clear question. What do you believe the Quran shall say about the marriage age? Tell me the words you want to see in the Quran talking about this
Читать полностью…
Human reason isn’t abandoned here it’s tested When knowledge increases, responsibility increases. If today we know early marriage is dangerous, then insisting on it isn’t obedience to God it’s ignoring both reason and ethics that God commanded us to use So I don’t see this as God being vague I see it as God giving a moral framework flexible enough to prevent harm in every age if people are sincere.
Читать полностью…
I get the point you’re making, and it’s a fair question. But I think the comparison isn’t quite equal.
The Qur’an gives numbers in matters where uniformity is necessary to avoid dispute or injustice like witnesses, waiting periods, or legal punishments. Those are areas where human bias or emotion could easily interfere, so clear limits were needed.
We have a number for lashes for fornication (100) becuz God clearly didn't trust humans to use their reason to decide the punishment
Читать полностью…
@Guy_dom
https://telegra.ph/Moses-people-02-08
you started this conversation by saying god failed to set a marriage age. well, that is your effort to avoid god's religion. you have a mind and you know what to do
Читать полностью…
Yesh, since we cannot reliably determine whether a girl is ready or not just by looking from the outside, it is better to set a clear age standard
Читать полностью…
i could be wrong if medicine says it is not a good age. doctors know better
Читать полностью…
If we use this logic, the problem with using Rushd as the rule for marriage is its subjectivity
1st. Who decides? In most cases, the judgment of the girl's maturity was decided by her father or male guardian. If a father wanted a political alliance or a dowry, he could easily claim his 10 yrs old daughter had sound judgment for her age
2nd. You can have the sound judgment to buy bread or manage a house at age 12 but your body does not have the sound judgment to survive a pregnancy
As I said earlier that people can't reliably determine whether a girl is ready or not just by looking from the outside, it is better to set a clear age standard
The Qur’an ties marriageability to bulūgh + rushd (physical maturity and sound judgment) not a number:
Surah An-Nisa4:6 - Test the orphans until they reach marriageable age; then if you find in them sound judgment (rushd)
Classical scholars like Ibn Kathīr and Al-Qurtubi explain that rushd includes mental and physical readiness, not just puberty
So early Islamic practice followed readiness and no harm, not a fixed age.
And what was the marriageable age followed by early Islamic society?
Читать полностью…
I think you’re mixing two different kinds of numbers the Qur’an gives.
The verses on breastfeeding and pregnancy (2:233 46:15) are descriptive not permissions for harm they describe natural biological maxima and responsibilities not thresholds that allow the opposite saying breastfeeding is up to two years doesn’t mean feeding a newborn solid food earlier would be acceptable if it caused harm the rule still stands harm is prohibited.
the completion of the human body does not vary significantly by climate
Читать полностью…
menstruation might start slightly earlier in some climates
But skeletal and cervical maturity do not
A 10 yrs old pelvis in 7th century Arabia is the same size as a 10 yrs old's pelvis in the 21st century London
Both are medically unready for the trauma of childbirth. A God would know this biological floor is universal, not subjective
And don't talk much because I don't like going into routes. Just tell me what you believe the Quran shall say
Читать полностью…
Surah Al-Baqarah 2:233 (Breastfeeding/Nursing for 2 years)
(46:15) Pregnancy period fixed (
for 6 months + 24 months for breastfeeding
Is this uniformity as well? Here Qur'an is clearly providing numbers for biological processes as well
Marriage is different The Qur’an doesn’t frame it as a single moment defined by a number but as a state of readiness physical mental and social Readiness isn’t fixed across time place, climate, health, or even individual A number would have frozen one historical context and forced it on all others Also, Islam already sets a strong boundary no harm If a marriage causes harm it is wrong even if society once saw it as normal Ignorance may explain why people didn’t recognize harm earlier but it doesn’t mean God left children unprotected The protection is the principle itself humans are accountable for how honestly they apply it as knowledge grows.
Читать полностью…
If God leaves the age up to human reason and human reason at the time is medically ignorant, then God is essentially leaving children at the mercy of that ignorance.
If people didn't know that early marriage caused the death, they wouldn't see it as a "sin" or "doing harm"
They would see it as a normal tragedy
The Qur'an did provide numbers for very specific, less life altering things. It gave numbers for breastfeeding (2 years), waiting periods (4 months) and even the number of witnesses for a loan.
If God felt that humans couldn't be trusted to use their reason to decide how long to breastfeed or how many witnesses to bring to a court case, why would he leave the most dangerous transition in a girl’s life (marriage/pregnancy) up to vague judgment?
didnt god give you a mind and tell you to use it and tell you marriage requires ability? what else do you need? need a number? that reminds me of moses people when they kept asking which cow
Читать полностью…
humans have a test in this world, they have to choose to do what is good, that is built-in knowledge everyone wants to ignore. but it is true. and told us to use reason and use sound judgement. you can decide what age of marriage suits you or your daughter. i dont know why you think god should set a minimum age. man knows right from wrong if his evil is not in control
Читать полностью…
health is crucial and should consider it first
Читать полностью…
Your maturity standards are assumptions developed by society which lacked biological information
Читать полностью…